Why Men Don’t Talk About Emotions — And How to Change That.

The Silent Struggle:
If you’ve ever heard a bloke say, “I’m fine” when he clearly isn’t, you’re not alone. It’s a script many of us have learned. For generations, young men have been raised to bottle things up, to soldier on, to toughen up. We’re told to keep it together, not crack under pressure, and above all, not to show weakness.

But here’s the reality: emotional silence is costing men their relationships, their mental health, and in some cases, their lives.

This post is about unpacking why so many young men struggle to talk about emotions, how it impacts their wellbeing, and what we can do about it—without sacrificing masculinity in the process.

Why Men Don’t Talk About Emotions

1. Cultural Conditioning: The "Be a Man" Message
From a young age, boys are bombarded with unspoken rules:

• Don’t cry.

• Don’t be soft.

• Don’t let them see you struggle.

The message is clear: vulnerability = weakness.

Pop culture, sport, schoolyard banter, even well-meaning parents often reinforce these ideas. So it becomes easier to wear the mask and stay quiet, even when things aren’t okay.

2. Fear of Judgement and Rejection
A lot of men don’t talk because they’re scared of the response.

• Will people think I’m broken?

• Will I lose respect?

• Will it make me seem weak?

The fear of being misunderstood or dismissed is real. And if someone has tried to open up in the past and been shut down, chances are they’ll retreat even further.

3. Lack of Emotional Literacy
You can’t express what you can’t name.
Many young men never learned the language of emotions. We’re great at recognising anger, but struggle to identify sadness, shame, guilt, or grief. It’s not just about speaking up—it’s about knowing how.

4. Role Models Who Didn’t Speak Up
Most men grew up around dads, uncles, or coaches who never spoke about their inner world. If no one ever modelled vulnerability in a healthy way, it’s hard to know what that looks like or where to start.

The Cost of Staying Silent

Bottling it up doesn’t make it go away. It just shows up in other ways:

• Anger or aggression

• Numbing out with alcohol, drugs or screens

• Relationship breakdowns

• Chronic stress, anxiety, or depression

Worse still, suicide remains the leading cause of death for Australian men aged 15-44.
This isn’t just a men’s issue—it’s a cultural crisis. And it needs to shift.

Masculinity and Vulnerability: They Can Coexist

There’s a growing conversation around healthy masculinity — and it’s not about ditching strength or stoicism, but expanding what it means to be strong.

Strength is facing your emotions, not running from them.
It’s having the courage to say, “I’m struggling” or “I don’t know what to do here.”
It’s about showing up honestly, for yourself and the people around you.

Vulnerability doesn’t make you less of a man. It makes you more human.

How to Start Talking: Practical Steps for Young Men

1. Learn the Language of Emotion
Use tools like a feelings wheel to help identify what’s actually going on beneath the surface. The more you can name it, the more you can navigate it.

2. Redefine What Strength Looks Like
Strength isn’t never feeling down. Strength is being real. Start seeing emotional expression as a skill to build, not a weakness to avoid.

3. Find Your Safe Spaces
This could be a mate, a coach, a therapist, or a men’s group. It doesn’t have to be everyone, but find at least one space where you can talk honestly, without judgement.

4. Practice, Don’t Perfect
You’re not meant to get it right straight away. Talking about feelings might feel awkward at first, but the more you practise, the more natural it becomes.

5. Support Other Blokes to Open Up
If you want better conversations, create better environments. That means:

• Listening without interrupting

• Not fixing or judging

• Sharing your own experience

Lead by example. You never know who’s watching.

Final Thoughts: A New Standard for Young Men

The world doesn’t need less masculinity. It needs a better version of it.

One where strength includes softness.
One where leadership includes listening.
One where connection beats performance.

If you’re a young bloke reading this, know this: you don’t have to carry it all alone. Speaking up doesn’t make you broken—it makes you brave.

Let’s raise the standard together.

Want more tools and conversations like this?
Join my online men's community MENtal Performance, or check out the blog for more content on mindset, masculinity, and mental performance.